Stonehill College in Massachusetts is a Catholic institution that actually lives its values without being heavy-handed about it. You get small classes, engaged faculty, and a campus culture that's genuinely kind without being saccharine. The liberal arts core is traditional but executed well, and the sense of community is real and not forced.
The business school is strong, and the sciences are solid. The location near Boston gives you access to internships and activities without being in the urban chaos. The Catholic identity is present (Mass is available, service is encouraged) but not oppressive for students of other faiths. The campus is attractive and walkable.
Fair warning: the price tag is steep, though merit aid is available. Best for students looking for a traditional liberal arts education, a supportive community, and the religious/values-driven foundation that Catholicism provides—even if you're not Catholic yourself, you'll encounter the institutional values.